Monday, December 15, 2014

St. John the Baptist; Second Sunday of Advent year B, December 7, 2014; The Rev'd Dr. Richard Smith



On the surface, Mark begins his gospel very matter-of-factly: The beginning of the good news of Jesus Christ, the Son of God.

But looks are deceiving; there’s more going on here than meets the eye. These are words of defiance. When Mark uses the terms “good news”  and “son of God”, he’s invoking terms used by Caesar, terms well-known in the Roman Empire of his day.

Back then, “Good news” was a political term. It was marketing hype that included all the official announcements about the Roman conquests, the victories of the Roman Legions, and their often brutal subjugation of many peoples--including Jesus’ own people, the Jews. Caesar’s good news inspired shock and awe.

In the opening line of his gospel, Mark co-opts this term from the Roman Empire to introduce a counter-story about a different kind of good news, a different vision for how life and the world can be. A vision based on love and mutual service, forgiveness, justice, mercy rather than on subjugation, domination, and brutal cruelty. Mark is writing a counter-story to that of Caesar, and it is an act of treason.

This is also the case when he refers to Jesus as the Son of God. In Mark’s day, that term referred to Caesar. Caesar was the Son of God, and here again, Mark is disrupting the story of the Empire by claiming that the real son of God is not Caesar but Jesus. 

For Mark, Caesar has it all wrong. Being son of God is not about power and control, but about laying down one’s life in love. The punchline in Mark’s gospel becomes clear when Jesus hangs from the cross, having just been executed by the Empire as a criminal. In that moment, a centurion who has just watched Jesus breathe his last declares, “Truly, this is the son of God”. It’s the supreme irony in Mark’s gospel, reflecting an understanding of what it means to be the Son of God that is very different from Caesar’s.

In our context today, we know well Caesar’s version of good news. We’ve seen the recent headlines about the killings of young African-Americans and Latinos by police officers: 

  • Eric Garner was a father who was selling single cigarettes to support his family. 
  • Michael Brown was a son heading off to college. 
  • Tanesha Anderson, a mental health patient, was in need of an evaluation and intervention. 
  • Tamir Rice was a twelve-year-old boy playing in the park. 
  • Alex Nieto, a student at San Francisco City College, was eating a burrito in Bernal Heights Park while on his way to work.
Each of them killed by police.

Suddenly, as we see the faces of many African-American and Latino mothers, the ancient words of the prophet Jeremiah ring eerily true: “A voice is heard in Ramah, lamentation and bitter weeping. Rachel is weeping for her children; she refuses to be comforted for her children, because they are no more.”

And our judicial system has failed them and all of us as Americans. Grand juries in Ferguson and Staten Island have refused to indict the officers who killed Michael Brown and Eric Garner, meaning those officers will never stand trial. Here in San Francisco, in the police killing of Alex Nieto, police have not released a witness list, not released the recording of a pertinent 911 call, not released the police reports, and not released the names of officers involved. This makes an independent investigation impossible. We’re forced to blindly trust what the police tell us. Given that no officer has ever stood trial for killing an unarmed black or Latino in this City, we have reason to be suspicious. It’s reasonable for us to want access to the available facts.

In our day, even in our City, we know well Caesar’s version of “good news” and how it manifests itself. 

In the very beginning of his gospel, Mark introduces the wild man John the Baptist who preaches repentance. Our spiritual ancestors realized that they had, knowingly or not, bought into Caesar’s story, and that if things were ever to change, they would first need to free themselves from that bitter story. They would need to repent, and so they wade into the muddy waters of the Jordan to be baptized by John.

And perhaps this is true for us as well--that, like our spiritual ancestors, we, too, knowingly or not, have bought into Caesar’s story. In our day, each of us in our own way have become complicit in the racism so deeply, often subtly, embedded in our culture and social institutions. And so, for us as for our ancestors, mountains must be leveled and winding ways made straight in order to find a new way. 

Years ago, in the pre-dawn hours of March 12, 1964, Kitty Genovese was assaulted and murdered in New York City. Her screams awakened at least thirty-eight neighbors who heard or watched how, for another half hour, her assailant stalked, stabbed, raped, and finally killed her. No one wanted to get involved or even call the police. The story attracted international attention. It was not just that many identified with the victim and understood that something like that could easily happen to them. Killings happen all the time.

What could account for the public’s fascination with this crime? Many who have studied the case attribute it to people’s deep-seated fear that, had they been there, they would have been the thirty-ninth silent witness. In this crime people caught a glimpse of the “bad Samaritan” in themselves.

The story of Kitty Genovese shines a light on our sense of being guilty bystanders in a cruel world. Today, with the recent police killings of young people of color, we are more aware of the scope of racism, the fact that we are all, especially if we are white, its beneficiaries if not its agents.

It’s not enough to say that we ourselves would never use the “N-word”, would never mug or kill or exploit others. In the war between good and evil, there is no neutral ground. All that is needed for evil to triumph is for good people to stand by silently. Martin Luther King used to say that he was more troubled by decent folks standing on the sidelines than by the racists who threw rocks.

The point is not to get down on ourselves but to awaken from a lonely hypocrisy. We are all caught up in this racist web. We too have bought Caesar’s version of “good news”. Better to feel our solidarity in sin and the need for repentance than to cling to a phony righteousness.

It is often said that the longing for liberation begins when you notice that you are in prison. Getting free to love requires facing up to our part in the sin, the racism, of the world. 

In today’s gospel, our spiritual ancestors wade into the muddy waters of the Jordan River. They come to John dissatisfied and desperate. They come for baptism with a look in their eye that says “God, I hope this works”. The past has become intolerable and they know they can’t go on as they are.

We in this country know that our racist past is no longer tolerable, that we can’t go on like this. And so on this second Sunday of Advent, we are invited to join our ancestors in the Jordan to confess our sin along with them, especially our sin of racism and our acquiescence to it, and to repent, to turn away from the story of Caesar and to gently turn a new way toward life, toward what Mark calls “the way of the Lord”. 

Tuesday, December 2, 2014

The Sheep and the Goats; Feast of Christ the King; November 30, 2014; The Rev'd Dr. Richard Smith


Ignacio (Nacho) Martin Baro (1942-1989)

Today is the last day of the year on the church’s calendar, and so the gospel speaks about the end times. Our thoughts turn to more ultimate things, ultimate in the sense of having utmost importance. Thoughts about how to measure a life, how to know whether it is successful or not.

It’s like what happens when someone approaches the end of their own individual life. They get a clarity about what is most important. Things that might have once mattered matter no longer. What is most important--for example, the love of family and friends--now becomes very clear; other things fall away.

Sometimes it’s good to look at our own context in which we are hearing the days’ gospel. This year we have a special context for hearing this particular gospel passage, for thinking these ultimate thoughts. I’m aware of three things going on at this moment in the world and in my own heart.

  • For one thing, the grand jury in Ferguson is about to announce their verdict in the case of the officer who killed Michael Brown. That verdict that will have broad implications for all of us Americans but especially for the many young brown and black people whose lives too often don’t matter within our larger American culture.
  • Secondly, last week, the President removed the fear of deportation from 5 million undocumented immigrants. It was a bold move on his part, and a hard-won victory for immigrants after hundreds of thousands of parents had been torn from their children. Still, it leaves 6 million people still under threat of deportation, including our immigrant LGBT sisters and brothers who remain particularly vulnerable.
  • Something else is going on as well, perhaps more personal to me. Last Sunday was the anniversary of the death of a friend of mine. I’ve been thinking of him all week. His name was Nacho. He was a Jesuit priest teaching at the University in San Salvador. Every Friday after he finished his classes, he would travel to one of the poorest barrios outside of town to offer the Eucharist and minister to the people there. Twenty-five years ago last Sunday, early in the morning, several armed soldiers raided the University where Nacho was teaching, dragged him, his fellow priests along with their housekeeper and her daughter into a small garden area and shot and killed them. They did this because Nacho and and the other Jesuits had given themselves heart and soul to the poor of that country who in those days were being rounded up and massacred left and right.


These are just a few parts of our context as we listen to this morning’s gospel, as we try to reconnect once more with the things that matter most in lives.

And, of course, what matters most is love. “In the evening, we will be examined on love,” St. John of the Cross once wrote. In the end, it won’t matter how much money you made, or the color of your skin. It won’t matter whether you looked like Miss America or Groucho Marx. The only thing that will matter is whether you tried to love with all your heart.
When I was hungry, Jesus will ask each of us, did you feed me? When I was thirsty, did you give me to drink? When I was naked, did you clothe me, or sick or in prison and visit me? When I was a stranger, an immigrant, did you welcome me?

These are the kinds of things we must do, what we each try to do. But notice: There is nothing uniquely Christian about them; all people with good hearts do these things whether they are Christian or not.

Still, I think there’s something unique about the way we Christians do them. After watching how Jesus lives and moves through the gospels, after spending time with him in prayer, after drinking in what we can of his Spirit, we come to do these good things in a uniquely Christian way. There’s a unique quality to the way the Spirit of Jesus goes about these good things.

For one thing, there’s a lack of calculation. jesus cautions us not to be like the goats. They’re the ones who say, “Lord, had we known it was you, we would have responded. But all we saw were these poor folks, some of them not looking not very well put together, some of them strangers who can’t speak English, some who don’t smell very good, some with criminal records. Why exactly would we want anything to do with them?”

There’s a Wall Street kind of calculation going on here: I’ll do this to get something in exchange. I’ll invest my time and energy and money caring for someone if it will yield me a good return of one kind or another--if not money, then perhaps some recognition or influence.

So the goats say, “If we had known it was Jesus, we would have responded--because we would have gotten something out of it: a place in the kingdom, a ticket to heaven. But to us, these folks didn’t look anything like Jesus. They just looked like just run-of-the-mill needy people, the kind who can’t repay us. So we did nothing for them.”

So goes the thinking of the goats with their quid-pro-quo calculations that constrict their hearts and short-circuit their love.

The sheep are not like this. They don’t calculate. No quid pro quo. They see people in need--people hungry, in prison, sick, people who are strangers, and they respond. They don’t even know that all along they are doing these things for Jesus. In fact they’re surprised to find that out at the end. Quite simply, they had seen people hurting and in need and so they responded. It’s very simple and pure, the way love is supposed to be.

Be like the sheep, Jesus is urging here. Love with his Spirit.

When Jesus sees a man with a withered hand, he doesn’t stop to do various mental gymnastics, asking whether it’s appropriate to heal on the sabbath, wondering how it will play out among the religious leaders if he were to heal the man’s hand. No, he simply sees this man in pain and he responds, he heals him.

And when Jesus comes upon a leper, one of the outcasts of his day, he doesn’t stop to consider what all the purity codes dictate and what the onlookers might be thinking. No, he just reaches out his hand and touches this man, this leper who probably had not been touched by anyone in years.

Simple. Pure. How love is supposed to be. Without calculation. It’s how Jesus does things.

There’s another unique way the Spirit of Jesus goes about feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, and visiting the imprisoned. It does these things without calling attention to itself.

When the religious hypocrites of Jesus’ day did good things, they would blow trumpets, stand on street corners, look glum so everyone would know they were doing some noble and heavy stuff. We may not be quite as dramatic as they, but we can certainly understand the need to be recognized, have our good actions noticed and applauded.

But when the Spirit of Jesus is at work in our actions, the need to gab about our accomplishments is not as strong as the need to be thankful for the grace that enables us, has caught us up and moves us along.

The other day after watching the President’s speech on immigration, I was complimenting a young Latina for the amazing work she had been doing for immigration reform. She said, “It’s all because of my mom who was always there for me and never lost faith that one day I could have a better life if she brought me to this country.” No need to promote herself or her abilities. She knew that what she did was enabled and supported by a grace from outside herself.

Years from now, when I get to heaven, I can imagine running into my friend Nacho. And if I ask him how he managed to end up in his cool new heavenly home, my hunch is he’ll say, “Well, I just tried to love everybody I could, freely, without calculation, and it was no big deal.”

Monday, November 10, 2014

The Ten Virgins Matthew 25:1-13; Proper 27; November 9, 2014; the Rev'd Robert Cromey


The parable of the ten virgins relates that the Kingdom of God is like a wedding banquet – FOOD, BOOZE, DANCING, kissing and great boisterous fun. The five foolish virgins were late to the wedding feast and were not allowed in.

Jesus message is “Keep awake therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour.” Jesus means we do not now when God’s kingdom will break in.

 The parable excludes latecomers. I don’t think so. I believe there is nothing you can do or believe that will stop God from loving you.

Jesus, a Jew of his time, believed the Kingdom of God, the end of history would happen in his lifetime. He also believed that if the Jews followed the law then God would save them. If you did not follow those rules, one would be cast out into outer darkness and would not achieve the love and presence of God.

After Jesus’ death the church evolved theologically so that many now believe, as I do, that there is nothing you can do or believe that will stop God from loving you.

But for today I want to focus on  “Keep awake therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour.” Jesus means we do not now when God’s kingdom will break in.

Living on the brink. We live on the brink every day. We can die in the blink of an eye, just like that.

Now that I have reached a certain age, 83 and a half, not a day goes by when I don’t thing “I could die, I could day at any moment. Then I go and have another cup of coffee and another piece of pie. I don’t dwell on death I merely note it. I’m not afraid of death, I don’t think about it a lot.

In the mid 1980s, when I led funerals for 75 plus gay young men, I thought of death a lot more than I do now. All of alive from those days remember that death was in the air.

We live every day on the brink of death from a nuclear bomb, a polluted air, water and land. Any bite we eat may kill us.

Immigrants in our own church or neighborhood live on the brink of deportation.

Brittany Maynard, a lovely East bay woman moved to Oregon where she could get assistance in dying. Oregon is a state where physician assisted death is legal, it is called Death with Dignity.  Ms. Maynard was diagnosed with aggressive brain cancer. In the days near her death she suffered from frequent seizures and severe neck and head pain. She chose to take life ending pills and soon died last weekend.

She said in an earlier video, ”I did this because I want to see a world where everyone has access to death with dignity.” There are five states Washington, Oregon, Vermont, Montana and New Mexico. California is not among them

Opponents to Death with Dignity are prevented from passing such legislation from the usual suspects. The Roman Catholic Church, the fundamentalist Christians like the Mormons and Southern Baptists and disabilities rights organizations, to name just a few.

We are always on the brink of new life, new possibilities, new friends, and new paths to justice.

The New Republican dominated Congress means we liberals have to trust the process of election wherever it takes us. I suspect we can handle the new problems and opportunities that will come our way under this new regime.

New babies. New loves, new lovers, New friends, new books, new TV shows.

A few weeks ago well-dressed woman, new in church, said hello to me after the service. I asked her name and she hesitated and said, “Sally. You are the first person I ever said my new name to. I am now a woman. I had the surgery. I felt so safe in this church.”

“I feel so safe in this church.”

Tuesday is November 11. Some of us remember that this used to be called Armistice Day. As kids we had a day off from school. On November 11, 1918 the First World War ended with Germany surrendering to the Allied forces. This war was called the “War to end all Wars.” That was 96 years ago.

The world thought we are on the brink of world peace.

But 21 years later Hitler’s armies invaded Poland and World War 11 began.

When Word War 2 was over, the United States has been waging war ever since from Korea through Afghanistan. Some us bear witness to peace.

People have stood vigil since the beginning of the war in Iraq. The vigil was started by the San Francisco Friends Meeting House. Many Episcopalians have joined in over the years. I stay for a half hour from 12 to 12:30 PM most Thursdays. Feel free to come for as long or short a period as you wish. There are plenty of signs provided by the Quakers. If you do not wish to receive these email, please just let me know. If you wish to add a name to the list, let me know that.

The Vigil takes place each Thursday from noon until 1:00 PM at the old Federal Building at the corner of Golden Gate Ave. and Larkin Street.

For more information about the weekly Thursday Vigil please contact me at my new email address robcro904@gmail.com.

We live on the brink of death but also of life, new life, new dreams, creativity and perhaps even the basic message of Jesus, food for the hungry, justice for all and peace.

Friday, October 31, 2014

The Greatest Commandment; Proper 25, October 26, 2014; The Rev'd. Dr. Richard Smith


The Pharisee in today’s gospel who asks which commandment is the greatest is trying to start a debate. There were over 600 laws. Choosing one as the greatest would pit Jesus against those who had chosen another. And, if all the laws were given by God as devout Jews believed, then aren’t all of them of equal weight? This Pharisee is trying to engage Jesus in a debate, but he is disappointed.

Because Jesus answers not by choosing one or two of the commandments, but by pointing to what undergirds all the law and the prophets, the very reason they were given by God in the first place: as a tool to help us love--love God, love each other.

For Jews, it is the very reason for doing all the things the law requires; for us Christians, it is the very point of our lives. It’s all about love--love of God, love of each other, love of this world. We’re down to basics here.

And it’s important now and then to make this explicit, so we don’t forget why we do all the wonderful things we do.

There’s that touching scene from “Fiddler on the Roof” where Tevya turns to his wife and asks, “Golda, do you love me?” She dismisses him, “Do I what? What a silly question! You must be stressed, maybe it’s indigestion. Go lie down.” But Tevye insists, “Do you love me?” Again, Golde shrugs him off. “For 25 years I've washed your clothes, cooked your meals, cleaned your house, given you children, milked the cow. And you ask, do I love you? Ha!” But Tevya stands his ground, asks a third time “Golde, I asked you a question: Do you love me?” And finally, Golde stops and she thinks quietly and then gives in. “Well, I guess I do.”

And Tevye replies, “You know, it doesn’t change a thing. But after 25 years, it’s nice to know.”

It was very important for Tevye to hear those words from his wife. It was equally important for Golde to hear herself say those words to her husband. It’s important now and then to make love explicit, otherwise we can lose sight of the forest for the trees, the reason we do all the amazing things we do, the love that undergirds them, makes sense of them.

What’s true of Tevya and his wife is true of us at St. John’s. We do many good things here:
In the past year:

  • We helped secure healthcare for working people in this City, 
  • We helped keep the adult day centers open to make it easier for seniors to stay in their homes.
  • We gave valuable input on the needs of LGBT seniors.
  • We’ve delivered a quiet but powerful message of peace and ending gun violence in our neighborhood through our Nightwalks and our work to pass Proposition 47, 
  • We’ve given out food for as many as 300 people/week through the Julian Pantry, 
  • We helped bring water to poor villages in Nicaragua, 
  • We’ve worked for immigration reform and helped the children who recently arrived at our border to have more adequate legal representation. Recently, we helped an immigrant family stay together when they were almost torn apart from an unjust deportation.
  • Week after week, we’ve stood for an end to war at silent vigils down at the Federal building.
  • Week after week, we’ve provided funds to people who are homeless, or needing a meal, or a little extra to pay the rent through the Vicar’s Discretionary Fund.

That’s is a lot for a small parish, and we should be proud of these things. But as this morning’s gospel reminds us, it’s not enough simply to do good things. What’s important is that these good things come from hearts full of love--our love for God, our love for each other, our love for this crazy world. Without love, as St. Paul puts it, we are a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal. Without love, we’re lifeless, dry, and empty, simply going through the motions.

Which is why we gather each week at this table to break the bread, sing our songs, and tell the story of Jesus. It’s here that we remember why we do the things we do, tap into the spiritual energy that inspires and supports our life and work together. It’s here that we make explicit what often goes unspoken throughout the week: that what we do comes from love, a love that we ourselves have received and tasted, a love that we now pass on to others.

And it’s from that same love that our parish leaders have invited us these last few weeks to give financially to this community as well. We give money to this community because we love--it’s as simple as that. We love each other, we love this crazy character we call Jesus, and we love this neighborhood and City with all their terrible beauty. We give financially to St. John’s because we love.

And there’s more and more about us to love.

  • We have a few little ones who will soon be ready for some formation and spiritual guidance of their own in Godly Play. While we’re getting things ready for them, with a little more money, we could hire an occasional babysitter to free their parents so they could more fully participate with us grownups in the Eucharist.
  • Our music has been greatly enriched with Aaron’s good work. The man knows how to play that organ! With a little more money, we could make some needed repairs to make that organ even more beautiful and powerful.
  • Our garden continues to be an oasis here in the Mission. We’re grateful for the enhancements that Dennis Turner is making possible in the bequest he gave us when he died. But for those enhancements to happen, we have some preliminary work to do. Some trees need some tending. With a little more money of our own and Dennis Turner’s generous bequest, we can guarantee that our garden remains a place of beauty for us and the people of this City for years to come.
  • And with a little more money, we can make some needed repairs to this building, like fixing those “thingies” on the tops of these columns that could come crashing down on your beloved vicar’s head at any moment. Just saying. With a little more money, we could make sure that this space remains both safe and beautiful for our worship and for the many in our neighborhood who rely on it: our friends from Mission Dharma, Friendship House, Mission Graduates, Volxkuche, the Aztec faith community, the Plaza 16 Coalition.

All of these things are within our reach. We can do them if we each do our part to share the financial load, if we are each as generous as possible.

Let me close with an old story from the rabbis. Two brothers owned a farm.  One brother was married and had several children, the other was single.  They shared the work equally, and they shared the fruits of the harvest equally as well, each with his own home, and each with his own barn.
Then one night, the single brother said, "It is not fair that my married brother and I share the harvest equally. He has several mouths to feed; he needs the grain more than I."  So that night, he took a sack of grain from his own barn and walked across the fields to put it into the barn of his brother.

That same night, the married brother said to himself, "It is not right that my brother and I divide the grain equally. When he gets old, he will have no one to take care of him. He needs the gran more than I."  He also took a sack of grain from his own barn and took it across the fields to his brother's barn.

This continued for some time. Each night the two brothers gave away their grain, yet each morning they found it had been miraculously replenished. They never told each other about this miracle.

Then one night, the inevitable happened. As the two brothers crossed the fields, each saw the other, each carrying a sack of grain. They realized at once what had been happening, dropped their loads and ran to embrace each other in laughter and tears.

The rabbis say that, on that very spot where the two embraced, the great temple of Jerusalem was built, because temples and mosques and churches like ours are built on those places where people embrace in laughter and in tears.

This is our story here at St. John’s. At the end of the day, it is love that builds this church.

Monday, October 13, 2014

The Man Without a Wedding Garment; Proper 23, Year A, October 12, 2014; the Rev'd. Dr. Richard Smith




So as you probably know by now, we’re in the midst of a special season in the church year. No, it’s not Christmas or Easter or Advent or Lent. It is rather the fundraising season!

There are many reasons why we members of St. John’s give our money to this parish. Probably we each have our own reasons. But speaking as your vicar, I hope that part of the reason we give to a community like St. John’s has something to do with today’s gospel. Let me explain.

I’m pretty sure this gospel is not about what we think it is about.

There's the old story of the pastor giving a children's sermon, where every week the children anticipate him making a new point about Jesus. This particular week he begins by holding up a stuffed squirrel and asking, "Boys and girls, do you know what this is?" Silence. The pastor asks again. Silence. Finally, one little boy is bold enough to shyly raise his hand and offer, "Gee, I know I'm supposed to say Jesus, but it sure looks like a squirrel to me."

If you’ve heard this morning’s gospel passage before, then something like that was probably happening in your own mind as you heard it again. Jesus, in his parables, often uses kings or lords as symbols for God. So as soon as he begins, "The kingdom of heaven may be compared to a king...," we immediately think this king is a metaphor for God.

But watch what happens: The king Jesus describes here is a cruel tyrant, flat out. This cruel king invites some folks to a wedding banquet; when they refuse, he blows them all away, sends soldiers who kill them all and burn their city. When the folks who are left alive in his kingdom hear what this king does to people who turn him down, is it any wonder the banquet hall is filled the second time around? Knowing what he did to the last invitees, would you turn him down?

The first people to hear this gospel story would have easily recognized who Jesus is talking about here. He’s retelling a well-known story, still fresh in everyone’s memory, about how King Herod took over Jerusalem.

You remember Herod, the king who slaughtered all the innocent children when he heard of Jesus’ birth, the one who later beheaded John the Baptist. Herod was a cruel tyrant.

Jesus is here retelling the story of how Herod had taken over Jerusalem. This had involved his joining his family with the ruling Jewish family in Jerusalem. Herod had invited the Jewish leaders and their followers to ratify the joining of these two powers. But they did not like him, they knew he was a cruel tyrant, so they refused. Because they refused, Herod attacked the city, burned much of it to the ground, slaughtered people left and right. Those who survived were brought under his rule by force, as virtual prisoners in their own city.

Today’s gospel is a retelling of that brutal story. Like Herod, the king in Jesus’ story first tries to win over the people by invitation. When they refuse the invitation, he slaughters them and burns the city. Those left alive are then brought into the marriage celebration by an offer they cannot refuse, by force.

But in his retelling of that brutal story Jesus adds a new twist. In his telling, one person refuses to go along with the program, refuses to dance and sing at the king’s wedding, refuses to wear a wedding garment. This man stands there defiant. When the king challenges him for not wearing the wedding garment, the man remains silent. The king then binds him hand and foot, and casts him out into the darkness where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth.

Some scripture scholars say that when Jesus describes this man without the wedding garment, he’s referring to himself. Jesus himself is the one who defies the Herods of this world, stands silent before those who accuse him of treason, offers a different way of living--the way of nonviolence, of forgiving even of one’s enemies, the way of love. As a result he is cast out and killed. This is what the kingdom of heaven looks like when it stands against Herod.
We have two competing worldviews here: that of Herod and that of Jesus. And in today’s gospel we’re invited to choose between them.

The fact is, we’re very familiar with the reign of Herod.

  • In Herod’s reign, a young gay man Matthew Shepard, the anniversary of whose death we remember today, gets tied to a lonely fence post, severely beaten, and left to die
  • In Herod’s reign, a young African American man in Ferguson, Michael Brown, is gunned down by police when he’s on his knees with his hands in the air.
  • In Herod’s reign, immigrant families like Ameli and Nicole whom we met last Sunday are torn apart by unjust laws.

This gospel passage puts the reign of Herod on display and invites us to choose between that reign and the reign of Jesus.

I like to think that here at St. John’s we choose the reign of Jesus, we create a space very different from the reign of Herod. In our best moments:

  • Members of this parish have tutored young people from this neighborhood, many of them fugitives from Central America in the 70s and 80s, to make sure they could finish high school and go on to college. The reign of Jesus.
  • Later, this parish became a home and a sanctuary to many gay men afflicted with HIV and ostracized from their families and churches. Many of them are now buried here in our garden. The reign of Jesus.

We still do this.

  • Every Saturday morning this space is hopping as the Julian Pantry distributes food to people from our neighborhood and City. The reign of Jesus.
  • Every Wednesday evening, proud young Native Americans gather here for a healing circle, make their beautiful native costumes, practice their powerful ancient dances. We provide this space to them. The reign of Jesus.
  • Twice each month a joyful evening of free food and entertainment is shared by people from our neighborhood and City. The reign of Jesus.
  • Last week, as I mentioned, we welcomed Ameli and Nicole, a mother and daughter, both immigrants who fled Guatemala for their lives. Ricardo, Ameli’s husband, is about to be unjustly deported to Guatemala where his life will once again be in danger. His wife and daughter came here to tell their story. We gave them our prayers and some money to fly to see Ricardo one last time before he is deported. They have been living under the cruel reign of Herod. But last Sunday, we showed them a different reign, the reign of Jesus.

Sometimes this happens in ways we’re not even aware of. A few Sundays ago, while I was getting ready for Mass, I saw a young man sitting quietly at the back of the church. I told him, “Hi, my name is Richard,” and told him was glad he could join us. He paused for a moment, then said very emphatically, “I am Will.” We chatted for a few moments, then I ran off to finish getting ready for Mass.

I saw Will a few more times in the following weeks, briefly saying hello each time. Then last Sunday he came up to me during coffee hour just as he was leaving. He said, “I just want you to know that I’ve been coming here while in town on a work assignment. That assignment is about to end, so I don’t know if I’ll be back again. But I want you to know before I go that this is the first place I’ve ever introduced myself as Will.”

Will is a transgendered male from another part of the country where people like him are neither understood nor welcome. While he was here at St. John’s, he looked around, saw who we are and how we are with each other. And, for the first time in his life, he felt safe enough to cross the threshold and introduce himself as Will. It’s what people do in the reign of Jesus.

In different ways we create a space very different from the reign of Herod. But most especially it happens week after week around this table as we gather--from university professors to street people; from beautiful toddlers and their parents to those of us in extreme middle age; from Filipinos and African-Americans to Caucasians and Latinos--all of us together, gathered around this table to tell the ancient stories of our spiritual ancestors, make Jesus present, and break the bread.

There are many reasons why we reach deep into our pockets to contribute our hard-earned cash to this community, and we each have our own reasons.

But ultimately it’s because we know that the alternative reign that Jesus invites us into is not some airy vision detached from the very real world in which we live. It is flesh and blood, brick and mortar. That kingdom happens in time and space. It happens right here, in this space, day after day, week after week.

And we want to be part of it, and we want it to be here for others as well. And so we contribute our money, to continue to make the reign of Jesus happen here, to make it real right here.

Thursday, September 25, 2014

Forgiveness; Proper 18, September 7, 2014, The Rev. Dr. John H. Eastwood

Teach me, O LORD, the way of your statutes, *
Give me understanding, and I shall keep your law; *
In my preparation this week for today’s service, I looked at the calendar and remembered

that this Thursday is the thirteenth year anniversary of that terrible day that has come to be

referred to as 9/11. As I studied the scriptures for today the themes of forgiveness, repentance, and

the commandment to love one’s neighbor as oneself arose. Those themes we find summed up in

the psalm for today which I chose as text for this sermon. Then I laid all that aside and thought

back to the discussions many of us remember in the days following that terrible time. There was

one conversation that sticks with me far more than anything else. It relates squarely on our texts

The conversation was an onstage TV panel discussion with audience about who made the

attacks and why they did what they did. It was about how we as a nation should respond and what

were our choices in responding. The panel was made up of prominent people from all walks of

life. What makes this conversation memorable is the statement of one panel member and the

response of the audience. He said, “In all the things we have said as a panel, I find there is

something missing. There is another response I think we should consider.” He paused, as if to

summon up some courage, then said, “I think we need to think about forgiveness.” The response

of the crowd was loud and predictable. A very angry and bordering on disgust “No way!” was

heard around the room. And it became a moment I have never forgotten.

I have never forgotten it for two reasons. The first reason comes from our understanding

that our responses to things that happen which hurt us often produce anger in one way or another.

It is our first line of defense as human beings and we will hold onto it as longs as we need to until

something happens to help us resolve and let go of it. The other reason is that there are just some

things we never get over. It may be a loss of relationship or a work suddenly disrupted. It could

be that we may know that we need to forgive someone, or allow ourselves to be forgiven, but the

resentments are so strong ­ whether they are about personal loss, or fear based prejudices ­ that

Unfortunately, we like to dwell on the negative. We tell ourselves over and over that we

should not have been treated in a certain way, or we plot imaginary approaches to revenge.

Shakespeare caught this trait in Brutus’ speech at Caesar’s death. “The evil that men do lives after

them; the good is oft interred with their bones.” In other words, because we are human, we find it

difficult to free ourselves from the negative in past events, and in people, including ourselves. Yet

healthy lives depend on our ability to let go. This is what we need.

The psalmist echoes our need and the path we need to take as he sings:

Teach me, O LORD, the way of your statutes, *

Give me understanding, and I shall keep your law; *

With wholeness of heart, body and mind, the psalmist sings the prayer to God, seeking to

be free of controlling darkness. He seeks to let go of the past that imprisons and move forward to a

future where resentment and revenge and have no place. In response, the lessons today remind us

of the great gift of love we are given and reminds us that forgiveness is the key that unlocks grace-
filled living. In the life of the Church, we see how this is played out. If we look back to the second

century of its existence, “See how these Christians love one another.” was the pagan observation of

the new quality of life among the members of the new sect, alive and growing in Paul’s Rome.

Since those days, the practice of Christian love through forgiveness has always been the Church’s

calling. It is a gift that Jesus gives his church, one not always easy to do. Yet we pray frequently,

sometimes daily, “And forgive us our sins, as we forgive those who sin against us.” It has not

been an easy path and the stumbling blocks are many.

Sometimes the church is blind to human need, absorbed in power struggles, and

preoccupied with itself. But they do not defeat us, they only make the task of forgiveness more

real. Sometimes newcomers to the church are turned away by church conflict. Another church or a

good place for brunch with friends might be a better alternative. But spiritual growth undertaken

seriously means learning to deal with the dark side of our nature and giving attention to how we as

a community can more faithfully use the gifts we are given. That is why our program here at St

John’s of listening in small groups has great potential for the growth of our own congregation. It is

one way to pursue concerns or issues that would divide us, and to find resolution. And there is

another opportunity for healing. At our healing station here at the Chapel steps, we can ask for

prayer to help our ability to forgive; healing takes many forms, spiritual as well as physical.

If we search the scriptures for our understanding about this love, we can find no better

place and no fewer words than those uttered at the cross. “Father, forgive them for they know not

what they do.” Martin Luther King called this “love at its best.” When Jesus was being plunged

into deep agony, and when human beings had stooped to their worst, God’s Son uttered words, not

of revenge, or thoughts of righteous wrath, but despised and rejected as he was, he cried, “forgive

them!” In him there was no darkness but only light, the light of forgiveness. And that is his great

gift to us. He says here, “forgive”, take it and use it.

In the reconciliation work after apartheid in South Africa led by Archbishop, there is a

wonderfully moving story told by him. His Committee held hearings for the nation in which

people were enabled to come forth to give voice through personal story, to their need to be

reconciled as a community. One time a police sergeant was confronted with some atrocities he had

committed. In one circumstance, he had taken a black man into captivity and shot him, point

blank, in the presence of his wife. Later, the same officer captured this wife’s only son, killed him

and brutalized his body. He admitted that he had done these things in court.

Then the wife and mother who was present was asked what she wanted in this situation.

She said, “I want three things. First, I want the sergeant to know that God forgives him, and so do

I. Second, I want him to come to my house one day each week and sit with me because I no longer

have anyone for a family. And third, I want to come forward now and hug the sergeant to prove

that my love is real.” The sergeant fainted ­ and the courtroom began quietly to sing, “Amazing

They, like the psalmist, had understanding. They understood how important it was to be

free of such evil. They understood, too, how free this woman felt by throwing aside her need for

revenge and accepting God’s forgiveness as a gift to be passed on. Is it possible that we know this

It is amazing what can happen to us when we allow ourselves to be embraced by love. It is

amazing how the grace of forgiveness can free us to walk with a lighter step, help us to walk

across the bridge over the river of pain that too often divides us from each other. Forgiveness is

God’s amazing grace. AMEN

Going into the vineyard; Proper 20, September 21, 2014; The Rev'd Richard Smith, Ph.D.

This past week I visited Ferguson, Missouri. I went to the place where Michael Brown was killed. I talked with one of his cousins, to several young people and mothers, to community organizers, and clergy.

Much of what I saw was not surprising. Since I’m a little cynical in my old age, since I’ve seen before how justice has worked--or not--in similar situations, I was not surprised that their consensus is that the officer who shot Michael will go free, that justice will not be served here.

Nor was I surprised at the many tears, the rage and the huge fear in the various young people I spoke with. Michael Brown’s death has opened up old wounds they have suffered for years from the police, and after the most recent trauma they had just been through with Michael's killing, the tears and rage and fear seemed like healthy and legitimate reactions. So these things did not surprise me.

But here’s what did surprise me. Today in Ferguson, so many people have been lifted out of their own little worlds into something very big.
As soon as he heard the news, a thirty-something white man they call Woo, who had moved away from Ferguson years ago, quit his construction job in Arkansas to come back home and work as a community organizer. “We’re all brothers and sisters,” he said.
A young African-American man named Mel who has had a bumpy ride on the planet--he’s a former gang-banger, a drug addict with a prison record and one failed relationship after another--is now part of a 24/7 encampment witnessing to what happened to Michael Brown and demanding justice. “In my whole life,” he told me, “this is the best thing I’ve ever done.”
A woman named Francesca whom I passed in a church hall was on her way to a meeting to learn what mothers like her could do to change the Ferguson City Council and get a new police chief. “This political stuff is all new to me,” she said, “But I gotta learn these things for my daughter’s sake.”
Then there was twenty-two year old Marcellus Buckley, a cousin of Michael Brown who was killed. To deal with his own sadness and anger and that of his community, he began writing poetry. He’s now known as “the poet of Ferguson” and has learned to say very powerfully what people in this small town are feeling.
Over and over again I saw people moving out of their own smaller worlds--their day-to-day concerns of earning a paycheck, buying groceries, doing the laundry--into something much larger, a deeper connection with each other and the larger world, an impulse to make things better for the many young African-American and Latino men who are far too often traumatized by the police. They have stepped into a much larger story, one in which they each have an important role to play.

It’s what happens in today’s gospel, which is a controversial one in a capitalist society like ours.

Laborers are hired, some early in the morning, some at noon, others at the end of the day. What sticks in our craw, and what is no doubt the focus of most sermons on this passage, is that they all get paid a full day’s wage, they all get paid the same. It doesn’t seem fair. If this gospel were trying to lay out best business practices for dealing with employees rather than a spiritual truth, there would be lawsuits.

But hold that thought, that controversy, for another time--and another sermon.

Today I’d like to focus on what’s on the landowner’s mind. For him, what matters is not what you get paid—he knows he’s going to give you everything you need, so that’s not a problem. Nor does he care about where you happen to be in the food chain, how high you’ve made it in the corporate ladder or the hierarchy. His concern is simply that you work in the vineyard, that you not waste your life on things that don’t really matter.

When he sees workers standing idle on the corner, he is pained. “Why are you standing here idle all day? You! Go into the vineyard.”This is a parable about the bigger picture, the larger story in which each of us is invited to play a part. Jesus calls it “the kingdom of heaven”. It is the dream of a new world, a new human reality. It is magnificent and wonderful. And like those day laborers eager to find work, like so many of the people of Ferguson in this critical moment, we, in our deepest hearts, are eager to be part of it. In our better moments, none of us wants to fritter away our precious time on this planet on things that don’t matter. It’s in our DNA. We want to live and live fully. And we want to be part of this great dream that God is bringing about all around us.

Ask people what they want in a job, and meaningfulness looms large. For decades, Americans have ranked purpose as their top priority -- above promotions, income, job security, and hours. Studs Turkel once interviewed hundreds of people in a striking array of jobs. He concluded that for us as for all people, work is a search "for daily meaning as well as daily bread." Yet all too often, we feel that our work doesn't matter. "Most of us,” he writes, “have jobs that are too small for our spirit. Jobs are not big enough for people."

This gospel is meant to bring us to a moment of clarity. It’s the kind of clarity people sometimes get when a tragedy like Michael Brown’s death happens.

In such a moment, we have a chance of getting our priorities straight. Suddenly all business-as-usual chatter in our heads doesn’t seem quite so important anymore. How much money do I make, how much weight I need to lose to fit into my jeans, how I compare with someone else. What does matter is that you are part of something vast and wonderful. You are not standing by idle, wasting your life. No, you, in your own way--in the way you do your job, or care for your friends and loved ones, or take part in the many ministries here at St. Johns’--are helping to build the kingdom of God. This, just knowing this, is all the reward you need. It’s what you were born for.
Because you’ve discovered something: That the Lord of the vineyard has said to you as to the laborers in today’s gospel, as to the people of Ferguson in this critical moment, “You, Go and work in my vineyard.”